Is plot a symptom? How folklorists study urban legends
Keywords:
urban legend, psychoanalytic hermeneutics, folklore articulation, folklore compensationAbstract
The article is dedicated to history and methods of urban legend studies. The author narrates the brief history of urban legend studies and covers upon some theoretical discussions concerning the terms “urban legend” and “contemporary legend”. Systematic research upon current folklore narratives began only in the 1940s, with contemporary legend becoming firmly established as an acclaimed research interest in the 1960s. Since the 1970s the issue of social reasons for emergence and popularity of certain plots becomes the key question of legend research. To answer it, folklorists follow the psychoanalytic “hermeneutics of suspicion”. They suggest that every legend contains a “hidden message” which needs to be perceived as a symptom of emotional status of the group. The author highlights two types of such psychoanalytic interpretation. Some researchers believe that legend’s function is articulation of nonconscious anxieties and fears of the group (the mechanism of folklore articulation, in terms of this paper). Other researchers suppose that a legend provides the group with an opportunity to compensate its moral discomfort (mechanism of folklore compensation). Nevertheless, the results of such interpretation were often arbitrary. This drew criticism in the 1990s, leaving the community in search of alternative explanations of why legends persist. But the question “Why?” is still unanswered. The theorists of ostension leave aside the issue of why a group produces and transmits a certain plot and focus upon how exactly the former is affected by the latter.Downloads
References
Алексеевский, М. (2011). Фольклористика между текстом и контекстом. Вестник РГГУ, 9(71), 42-57
Архипова, А., Кирзюк, А., Титков, А. (2017). Чужие отравленные вещи. Новое литературное обозрение, 143(1), 154-166
Вахштайн, В. (2014б, 4 апреля). К теории подозрения [лекция]. Постнаука. Режим доступа: https://postnauka.ru/longreads/24674
Дандес, А. (2003). Проекция в фольклоре. В защиту психоаналитической семиотики. В Дандес, А. (Авт.), Архипова, А. (Сост.). Фольклор. Семиотика и/или психоанализ. Сб. статей, 72-107. М.: Восточная литература
Кирзюк, А. (2017). Три черных "Волги": молчание и страх в советских городских легендах. Новое литературное обозрение, 143(1), 167-177
Лакан, Ж. (1999). Семинары. "Я" в теории Фрейда и технике психоанализа, 2 (1954-1955). М.: Логос
Ланская, Ю. (2006). Американская городская легенда в контексте постфольклорной культуры (Aвтореферат диссертации на соискание ученой степени кандидата филологических наук). Удмуртский институт истории, языка и литературы Уральского отделения РАН, Ижевск
Луман, Н. (2007). "Что происходит?" и "Что за этим кроется?". Две социологии и теория общества. Социологическое обозрение, 6(3), 100-117
Майер, А. (2008). Московские городские легенды как исторический источник: историческая память и образ города (Aвтореферат диссертации на соискание ученой степени кандидата исторических наук). Институт всеобщей истории РАН, Москва
Новичкова, Т. (2001). Эпос и миф. СПб.: Наука
Осетрова, Е. (2011). Слухи в современной социокультурной среде: историографический обзор. Антропологический форум, 2011(15). Режим доступа: http://www.intelros.ru/pdf/Antropo_Forum_online/2011_15/osetrova.pdf
Панченко, А. (2014). "Спасибо за почку!": Власть и потребление в organ theft legends. Этнографическое обозрение, 2014(6), 22-42
Панченко, А. (n.d.). Легенды [лекция]. Режим доступа: http://folk.spbu.ru/Reader/panch.php?rubr=Reader-lectures
Платт, К. (2010). Зачем изучать антропологию? Взгляд гуманитария: вместо манифеста. Новое литературное обозрение, 2010(106). Режим доступа: http://magazines.russ.ru/nlo/2010/106/ke4.html
Поппер, К. (1983). Логика и рост научного знания. М.: Прогресс
Поселягин, Н. (2012). Антропологический поворот в российских гуманитарных науках. Новое литературное обозрение, 2012(113). Режим доступа: http://www.nlobooks.ru/node/1739
Равинский, Д., Синдаловский, Н. (1995). Современные городские легенды: Петербург. Живая старина, 1995(1), 5-8
Фрейд, З. (1989). Введение в психоанализ: лекции. М.: Наука
Baughman, E. W., Holaday, C. A. (1944). Tall tales and "sells" from Indiana University students. Hoosier Folklore Bulletin, 3(4), 59-71
Beardsley, R. K., Hankey, R. (1943). A history of the vanishing hitchhiker. California Folklore Quarterly, 1943(2), 13-25
Bell, L. (1976). Cokelore. Western Folklore, 1976(35), 59-64
Bennett, G. (1984). The phantom hitchhiker: Neither modern, urban nor legend? In P. Smith (Ed.), Perspectives on Contemporary Legend, 45-63. Sheffield: Sheffield Academy Press
Bennett, G. (1997). Bosom serpents and alimentary amphibians: A language for sickness. In M. Gijswijt-Hofstra and H. Marland (Eds.). Illness and Healing Alternatives in Western Europe, 224-242. London: Routledge
Bennett, G. (2005). Bodies: Sex, violence, decease, and death in contemporary legend. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi
Bennett, G., Smith, P. (Eds.). (1990). Contemporary legend. The first five years. Abstracts and bibliographies from the Sheffield Conferences on Contemporary Legend. 1982-1986. Sheffield Academy Press
Bennett, G., Smith, P. (Eds.). (1991). Contemporary legend: A folklore bibliography. New York and London: Garland
Bennett, G., Smith, P. (Eds.). (1996). Contemporary legend: A reader. New York: Garland
Best, J., Horiuchi, G. (1985). The razor blade in the apple: The social construction of urban legends. Social Problems, 32(5), 488-499
Brunvand, J. H. (2012). Encyclopedia of Urban Legends. 2th ed. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO
Brunvand, J. H. (1980). Urban legends: Folklore for today. Psychology Today, 1980(June), 50-62
Brunvand, J. H. (1981). The vanishing hitchhiker. American urban legends and their meanings. New York, London: Norton & Company
Brunvand, J. H. (1986). The Mexican pet: More "new" urban legends and some old favorites. New York: Norton Company
Brunvand, J. H. (1993). The baby train and other lusty urban legends. New York: Norton
Campion-Vincent, V. (1976). Les histoires exemplaires. Contrepoint, 1976(22/23), 217-232
Campion-Vincent, V. (2005). Organ theft legends. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi
Campion-Vincent, V., Renard, J.-B. (2005). De source sur: Nouvelles rumeurs d'aujourd'hui. Paris: Éditions Payot
Carpenter, A. (1976). Cobras at K-Mart: Legends of hidden danger. Publications of the Texas Folklore Society, 1976(40), 36-40
Carroll, M. (1992). Allomotifs and the psychoanalytic study of folk narrative: Another look at "The roommate's death". Folklore, 103(2), 225-234
Clements, W. (1991).Interstitiality in Contemporary Legend. Contemporary Legend, 1991(1), 81-92
Cunningham, K. (1979). Hot dog! Another urban belief tale. Southwest Folklore, 1979(3), 27-28
Dégh, L. (1968a). The hook. Indiana Folklore, 1(1), 92-100
Dégh, L. (1968b). The runaway grandmother. Indiana Folklore, 1(1), 68-77
Dégh, L. (1971). The "belief legend" in modern society: Form, function and relationship to other genres. In W. Hand (Ed.). American folk legend: A symposium, 55-68. Berkeley, Los-Angeles: University of California Press
Dégh, L., Vázsonyi, A. (1983). Does the word "Dog" bite? Ostensive action: A means of legend. Journal of Folklore Research, 20(1), 5-34
DiFonzo, N., Bordia, P. (2007).Rumor, gossip and urban legends. Diogenes, 2007(213), 19-35
Domowitz, S. (1979). Foreign matter in food: A legend type. Indiana Folklore, 1979(12), 86-95
Donaghey, B. S. (1978). The Chinese restaurant story again: An antipodean version. Lore and Language, 2(8), 24-26
Dorson, R. M. (1959). American folklore. Chicago, University of Chicago Press
Dundes, A. (1971). On the psychology of legend. In W. Hand (Ed.). American folk legend: A symposium, 21-36. Berkeley, Los-Angeles: University of California Press
Dundes, A. (1993). Series editor's preface. In G. Bennett and P. Smith (Ed.). Contemporary legend: A folklore bibliography, ix-xiii. New York and London: Garland
Edgerton, W. B. (1968). The ghost in search of help for a dying man. Journal of the Folklore Institute, 5(31), 38-41
Ellis, B. (1983). De legendis urbis: Modern legends in Ancient Rome. Journal of American Folklore, 1983(96), 200-208
Ellis, B. (1987). Why are verbatim transcripts of legends necessary? In G. Bennette and P. Smith (Eds.). Perspectives on contemporary legend, 1987(2), 31-60. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press
Ellis, B. (1989). Death by folklore: Ostension, contemporary legend, and murder. Western Folklore, 48(3, Jul.), 201-220
Ellis, B. (1994). "The hook" reconsidered: Problems in classifying and interpreting adolescent horror legends. Folklore, 1994(105), 61-75
Ellis, B. (1997). Legend, urban. In T. A. Green (Ed.). Folklore: An encyclopedia of beliefs, customs, tales, music, and art, 495-497. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO
Ellis, B. (2003). Aliens, ghosts, and cults. Legends we live. Jackson: University Press of Missisipi
Ellis, B. (2009). Whispers in an ice cream parlor: culinary tourism, contemporary legends, and the urban interzone. The Journal of American Folklore, 122(483, Winter), 53-74
Ellis, B., Fine, A. G. (2010). The global grapevine: Why rumors of terrorism, immigration, and trade matter. Oxford: Oxford University Press
Fine, G. (1979). Cokelore and coke law: Urban belief tales and the problem of multiple origins. The Journal of American Folklore, 92(366), 477-482
Fine, G. (1980). The Kentucky fried rat: Legends and modern society. Journal of the Folklore Institute, 17(2/3, May-Dec.), 222-243
Fine, G. (1985).Rumors and gossiping. In T. Van Dijk (Ed.). Handbook of discourse analysis, Vol. 3: Discourse and dialogue, 223-237. London: Academic Press
Georges, R. (1971). The general concept of legend. In W. Hand (Ed.). American folk legend: A symposium, 1-19. Los-Angeles: University of California Press
Goldstein, D. (2004). Once upon a virus: AIDS legends and vernacular risk perception. Logan: Utah State University Press
Heath, Ch., Bell, Ch., Sternberg, E. (2001). Emotional selection in memes: The case of urban legends. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(6), 1028-1041
Henken, E. (2004). Gender shifts in contemporary legend. Western Folklore, 63(3, Summer), 237-256
Hobbs, S. (1966). The modern folk tale. Chapbook, 3(4), 9-11
Kapferer, J.-N. (1987).Rumeurs. Le plus vieux media du monde. Paris: Editions du Seuil
Morin, E. (1969). La rumeur d'Orléans. Paris: Édition du Seuil
Mullen, P. (1970). Department store snakes. Indiana Folklore, 1970(3), 214-228
Oring, E. (2014). Memetics and folkloristics: The applications. Western Folklore, 73(4), 455-492
Pettit, Т., Smith, P., Simpson, J. (1995). Contemporary legend: The debate continues. Folklore, 1995(106), 96-100
Renard, J.-B. (1999).Rumeurs et légends urbains. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France
Simpson, J. (1983). Urban legends in the pickwick. The Journal of American Folklore, 96(382), 462-470
Smith, P. (1984). On the receiving end: When legend becomes rumour. Perspectives on Contemporary Legend, 1984(1), 197-215
Smith, P. (1989). Contemporary legend: A legendary genre? In G. Bennette, P. Smith (Eds.). Perspectives on Contemporary Legend, 1989(4), 91-102. Sheffield: Sheffield Academy Press
Smith, P. (1997). Contemporary legend. In A. T. Green (Ed.). Encyclopedia of beliefs, customs, tales, music and art, 493-495. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO
Turner, P. (1993). I heard it through the grapevine: Rumor in African-American culture. Berkeley, University of California Press
Victor, J. S. (1993). Satanic panic. The creation of a contemporary legend. Chicago and La Salle, Illinois: Open Court
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
How to Cite
Коды статьи
- EDN RVUKEK
- Тип статьи (РИНЦ) Научная статья (Научная статья)
